Moscow Times
June 20, 2008
Everyone Pays, Few Want To Stop
By Francesca Mereu / Staff Writer
Editor's note: This is the third in a series of reports about the key challenges facing Russia today. Previous reports can be found at www.themoscowtimes.com.
The Moscow police officers checked Viktor's office and declared that he was in big trouble.
The Windows software installed on his computers was not licensed, and the officers said they would be forced to open a criminal case unless Viktor showed his "generosity."
Viktor slapped $6,000 into the hand of one of the officers, and the pirated software was forgotten.
Across the city, Igor is proud of his brand-new Ford Focus, but he parked it several hundred meters away from the institute where he studies medicine. If his professors were to see it, he would be charged more money to pass his exams.
In a small shop on Prospekt Mira, Yekaterina regularly pays tax officials to turn a blind eye to irregularities in her accounting records and fire inspectors to ignore fire safety violations.
"This is the way we live. We pay, pay and pay," Yekaterina said with a sigh.
People living in Russia pay $319 billion a year in bribes, according to Indem, a Moscow-based research center that tracks corruption. That amounts to about $2,250 for each of the country's 142 million citizens.
The cost of corruption is keenly felt across all segments of the economy, pushing up prices for food, housing, services, health care and education. A few people have taken a stand against bribes, opting instead to take the longer and sometimes more costly route of doing everything above board. But many people prefer the status quo, saying they fear a government-led reform effort would end up forcing them to pay more than they do now.
President Dmitry Medvedev has declared war on corruption, and he is expected to outline a national anti-corruption plan in the upcoming days. The plan, prepared by the Anti-Corruption Council, a body that Medvedev founded and chairs, is to seek amendments to laws that breed corruption, offer protection to businesses from corrupt bureaucrats, and make judges independent.
Corruption, however, is deeply engrained into everyday life. Everyone pays bribes, according to a study carried out last year by Transparency International, a corruption watchdog. The study ranked Russia on par with Gambia, Togo and Indonesia in terms of corruption, ranking it in 143th place out of 180 countries surveyed.
As the cost of living rises, so has the cost of the average bribe, increasing from $10,000 in 2001 to $130,000 in 2005, according to Indem. The largest chunk of bribes go to law enforcement agencies and education institutions, it said.
It is little wonder then that Russians overwhelmingly believe that bureaucrats became less efficient and more corrupt under President Vladimir Putin, as documented in a study by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences in late 2005.
Indeed, corruption has become more "impudent and open," compared with President Boris Yeltsin's time in office, said Georgy Satarov, the head of Indem.
"Bureaucrats who took bribes used to try to hide them, but now they are not even afraid of showing off their wealth," Satarov said.
Fighting With Legislation
As a first step, Medvedev has ordered new legislation to prevent state inspectors from entering the premises of small businesses without the permission of prosecutors.
"Arbitrary inspections by officials -- from firemen to the police -- are often an excuse to extort bribes from small firms and must halt," he told a State Council meeting in Tobolsk in late March.
Under Medvedev's direction, the Duma Commission to Fight Corruption has drafted a bill to fight corruption that would deprive officials of opportunities to use their positions for personal profit and set strict standards for government employees. The bill requires officials and members of their families to declare their property and forbids former officials from working for companies that they previously regulated.
The rules were taken from a United Nations convention against corruption and a Council of Europe convention on criminal responsibilities that the Duma ratified two years ago and needs to implement, said Mikhail Grishankov, one of the authors of the bill and the head of the Duma Commission to Fight Corruption.
"We didn't try to create something completely new," Grishankov said in an interview. "Instead, we looked at international experience in this field."
Grishankov said the anti-corruption bill contained provisions that have been tested in Western countries and worked well.
"We don't have any illusions that by applying European measures we will get immediate results. But there are rules that have been applied in other countries and work," he said.
Medvedev will present the bill to the entire Duma for a vote in the fall, and the bill will be passed by year's end, Grishankov said.
Other anti-corruption legislation is also in the works. The Investigative Committee, linked to the Prosecutor General's Office, has floated a bill that would eliminate a legal loophole that allows government officials to accept gifts worth less than 11,500 rubles.
Putin's campaign against corruption largely consisted of raising bureaucrats' miserly salaries to make bribes less attractive and the occasional high-profile arrest of corrupt officials in sting operations.
At his last annual Kremlin news conference in February, Putin admitted that the campaign had failed and said he could not think of a more difficult problem to solve. "Fighting corruption takes time, and there is no miracle anti-corruption pill that the state can swallow and cure its corruption woes overnight," he said.
He accused big businesses of facilitating corruption by placing their people in the government. "Few of these people actually received a salary in these posts. It was not the money that interested them," he said.
Putin has dismissed the idea of replicating attempts by Georgia to get rid of corruption as unpractical and unrealistic. Georgia fired its entire traffic police force and replaced the officers with new recruits.
'Don't Touch Anything'
Told about the pending legislation, Viktor, the businessman with pirated software, unleashed a torrent of profanity.
"Don't touch anything! Let things stay the way they are," he said, shouting. Viktor, like many small entrepreneurs interviewed for this report, spoke on condition of anonymity, citing fears of reprisals from the authorities.
Viktor said he spends about $1,000 a month on bribes to police officers and bureaucrats. The money pays for permits and prevents inspectors from revoking his license for perceived infractions. He said the bribes were like an extra tax, which, although high, is manageable. He said he "strongly" opposes Medvedev fighting the problem.
"I don't like paying bribes, and I would rather work according to clear and transparent rules," Viktor said. "But I live in Russia, and experience tells me that every time authorities decide to tackle a problem, things only get worse."
Yekaterina, who pays $800 to tax and fire inspectors every month, said she feared a government crackdown would only lead to higher bribes. "It would become riskier for bureaucrats to take the money, so they would ask for more," she said.
"It is better to leave things the way they are," she added. "It is not an easy situation, but now we can survive. If they touch anything, it would be the end for small businesses."
Viktor and Yekaterina explained that they have good relations with "their" officials, and a change would mean building new relations with new people who might want more money.
"It took me so long to establish my contacts, and I don't want to lose them," Viktor said. "The old ones already have cars and apartments."
But Igor, the student with the new car, said he supported any government initiative to stop bribery at schools. At his institute, he said, only students from poor families pass exams for free, but professors ask for money from students from middle-class or rich families.
"I like studying, but I sometimes lose motivation because I know that I can pay and the exam is done," Igor said. "Who studies under such circumstances? People get degrees without even opening a book."
Satarov said "everyday corruption" is the worst kind, when students pay professors for a degree and people pay doctors for treatment.
Already in 2001, he said, 2 million adults reported that they did not seek treatment when they were ill because they could not afford to pay for nominally free public health care services.
"This kind of corruption will bring unimaginable danger in our society," Satarov said. "People will be unhealthy, and soon we will have lawyers, constructors and doctors who have all purchased their degrees."
One Man's Fight
Ilya Khandrikov, a businessman who owns a clothing factory with 110 workers, started his own fight against corruption in 2006 after growing weary of being harassed by policemen and fire and tax inspectors. He stopped paying bribes.
When officials stop by his office looking for a handout, he refuses. When he needs to get a new permit, he hires a firm that takes care of the bureaucratic hurdles for him.
"It is a big challenge," he said. "Some people say, 'You'd better pay,' but I'm a fighter by nature."
Khandrikov said it was difficult to compete with rival businesses that prefer the easier way of paying bribes, but he believes that someone has to oppose the system before things will start to change.
"It takes more time and money to solve the problems the way I do, but still I decided to stop giving money to anyone anymore," he said. "It is more expensive, but it is worth it."
Khandrikov believes that corruption would end if all businesses followed his example.
A few other businesses are also openly refusing to pay bribes, including Ernst & Young, the auditing firm, which encourages clients to follow its lead. "If a company wishes to get recognition from its Western partners, it should have a zero-tolerance policy toward any corruption payments," Ivan Ryutov, head of fraud investigation and disputes services at Ernst & Young, said in an e-mail. "That is why we always recommend that our clients think about their image and reputation rather than entering into dubious corruption schemes."
Grishankov, the Duma deputy, said businesspeople are one of the main problems in fighting corruption. "When businessmen understand that the rules are changing and they need to follow the law like everyone else, things will gradually start to improve," he said.
Solution Is Democracy
Is there a way out of corruption? Satarov said the solution is simple: allow nongovernmental organizations and the media to provide external control over bureaucracy.
"The bureaucracy is now independent and without any controls. It does whatever it wants," Satarov said. "When bureaucracy is without any controls, it works for itself, and then you have corruption."
To fight corruption, Satarov said, Russia needs free NGOs and free media, as well as a developed civil society, political competition and a clear division of powers in the government.
"In one word: democracy," he said. "Without these conditions, any fight against corruption is useless. You will only get short-time results."
Punitive measures are unlikely to work in a big country like Russia. "In some small countries like Singapore, it is possible to fight corruption with strong punitive measures, but not in Russia," Satarov said.
Yelena Panfilova, head of the Russia office of Transparency International, said the authorities needed to work to change people's mentality so that they understood that life without corruption would be better for everyone. Putin often launched anti-corruption campaigns around election seasons, and people tend to associate them with election-time politicking.
"The political leadership should make it absolutely clear that this time they are fighting corruption seriously, that they are not going to stop when the elections are over," Panfilova said.
In educating the public about corruption, the government must make people realize the price they pay everyday because of corruption, she said.
"When people see that Coca-Cola is 5 rubles more expensive, they blame greedy businessmen," she said. "But they don't see that the reason for the price increase is not economic but corruption."
People also do not associate the danger in the streets with corruption, said Kirill Kabanov, director of the National Anti-Corruption Committee, an advocacy group. "Patrol officers in our country are on the street to make money, not to protect citizens," he said.
At least one Moscow police officer is not worried that Medvedev's drive against corruption will change the way he works.
A police officer, who works for the Moscow force's anti-organized crime division, is more skeptical about the fight against corruption the government wants to start.
"It is just a publicity stunt to promote the new president and to show people that he wants to find a solution to this problem," said the officer.
He said bureaucrats were so used to taking money that they would continue the practice even if their salaries were raised by 10 times.
"The only thing to fight this problem is to replace everyone from the top to the bottom with new people," he said.
--------
The Problem: Corruption
What the Government Is Doing
President Dmitry Medvedev set up the Anti-Corruption Council, which he chairs, and is expected to unveil a national anti-corruption plan soon. The thrust of the plan is to tackle corruption by tightening existing laws, protecting businesses from corrupt bureaucrats and making judges independent.
Legislation is being drafted to bring the law in line with international norms by requiring officials and members of their families to declare their property and forbidding former officials from working for companies that they previously regulated. Proposed legislation also would ban bureaucrats from accepting all gifts.
The Solution
Allow nongovernmental organizations and the media to serve as independent watchdogs over bureaucracy.
Promote democracy by creating clear divisions of power within the government and fostering political competition, civic society, free NGOs and free media.
Educate the population about the high price that corruption carries and the positive benefits for everyone when it is squashed.
-- MT
--------
The Cost of a Bribe
The Institute for Public Projects and the Institute for Comparative Social Research compiled a price list for bribes based on interviews this year with 36 anonymous experts connected with various business and public sectors. Politics
A place on a party list for State Duma elections: $2 million to $5 million.
Getting a bill into the Duma: $250,000
Government monopolies
For a state monopoly to get a state purchase order: 20 percent of the project's total value.
To participate in a national project: 30 percent to 40 percent of the project's total value.
Big businesses
To get a license or to prevent one from being revoked: $1 million to $5 million
To get a state purchase order: one-third of the project's total value.
Small businesses
To get a transaction carried out: one-third of the transaction's total value.
To get help from officials: 10 percent of the profit received due to the assistance.
Customs
Getting duties reduced: 30 percent to 50 percent of the tax money saved.
Taxes
To get tax arrears written off: from $1,000 to 30 percent to 50 percent of the arrears.
Banks
To get the Central Bank to begin examining a document: $500,000
To get the right to transfer federal budget funds: 5 percent of the sum of each transfer.
Civil and Arbitration Court
To win a case: 10 percent of the awarded damages
NGOs
To win a grant: 20 percent to 30 percent of the grant.
Media
To get a television personality to criticize an official: $20,000 a month.